Le has brought a passage that runs straight across the end of chapter 1 into chapter 2, and that is exactly how it should be read.
The chapter divisions in our Bibles were added more than a thousand years after Paul wrote. He did not put one here, and this is one of the places where it does real damage.
Because chapter 1 ends by describing what God's power did to Christ — and chapter 2 says the same three things happened to us.
Read as one paragraph, the argument is unmistakable. Read as two chapters, most people miss it entirely.
"As for you, you were dead in your transgressions and sins, in which you used to live when you followed the ways of this world and of the ruler of the kingdom of the air...
All of us also lived among them at one time, gratifying the cravings of our flesh and following its desires and thoughts. Like the rest, we were by nature deserving of wrath."
Paul's diagnosis is blunt and it is deliberately chosen. Not weak. Not sick. Not heading in the wrong direction. Dead.
Which rules out an entire category of remedies. A sick man can be treated, a lost man can be given directions, a weak man can be trained. Nothing at all can be asked of a dead one.
And note that Paul does not exempt himself. He begins with you — the Gentile readers — and then in verse 3 turns and says all of us also. The apostle, the Pharisee, the man who had kept the law from his youth, puts himself in the same sentence.
This is the honest floor of the passage, and everything after it depends on the floor being that low. Grace looks like a courtesy to people who were merely struggling. It looks like resurrection to people who were dead.
Then verse 4 begins, and everything changes on two words. But God. Mais Dieu.
Three verses of diagnosis — dead, following, gratifying, deserving — and the whole weight of it is reversed by a conjunction and a noun.
Nothing in verses 1 to 3 improves. No one repents in them. The situation does not develop. What happens is that a new subject enters the sentence.
And notice the order of what follows, because Paul puts the motive before the action. Because of his great love for us, God, who is rich in mercy... Before we are told what He did, we are told why. The love came first, and it was directed at people described one verse earlier as deserving wrath.
"But because of his great love for us, God, who is rich in mercy, made us alive with Christ even when we were dead in transgressions — it is by grace you have been saved.
And God raised us up with Christ and seated us with him in the heavenly realms in Christ Jesus, in order that in the coming ages he might show the incomparable riches of his grace, expressed in his kindness to us in Christ Jesus."
"Mais Dieu, qui est riche en miséricorde, à cause du grand amour dont il nous a aimés, nous qui étions morts par nos offenses, nous a rendus à la vie avec Christ (c'est par grâce que vous êtes sauvés); il nous a ressuscités ensemble, et nous a fait asseoir ensemble dans les lieux célestes, en Jésus-Christ."
Éphésiens 2:4–6 · Louis Segond 1910Here is the structural heart of the passage, and the French shows it where the English cannot.
Paul uses three verbs in verses 5 and 6, and he has built all three as compounds beginning with syn- — the Greek prefix meaning together with.
Made alive together with. Raised together with. Seated together with.
The Segond keeps it visible: il nous a ressuscités ENSEMBLE, et nous a fait asseoir ENSEMBLE dans les lieux célestes.
Now look back one paragraph, at what Paul said God did to Christ. He raised Christ from the dead and seated him at his right hand in the heavenly realms.
Raised. Seated. In the heavenly realms. The same two verbs, the same location, in the same order — first of Christ, then of us.
Which is why the chapter break is such a loss. Paul spent chapter 1 asking that they might know the greatness of God's power, and pointed at the resurrection as the measure of it. Then he says: and that same power was applied to you. Not power like it. The same act, extended.
There is a small human detail in verse 5 that is easy to miss. In the middle of a long sentence, Paul breaks off and inserts a parenthesis: it is by grace you have been saved.
He is going to say it properly three verses later, in verse 8, where it belongs in the argument. He says it here anyway.
It is an interruption of his own grammar. The Segond keeps it in brackets, as an aside: (c'est par grâce que vous êtes sauvés).
Which is the same man whose grammar ran out of breath in chapter 1, and for the same reason. He cannot get to the end of a sentence about grace without stopping to say the word.
Verse 7 gives the purpose, and it is not the one most people would guess. In order that in the coming ages he might show the incomparable riches of his grace.
The stated reason is a demonstration. God saved us in order to have something to show.
And what is displayed is not us. It is the riches of His grace, expressed in his kindness to us. We are not the exhibit. We are the evidence.
Which is the same shape as the chorus Le read two days ago, three times over: to the praise of His glory. Every stanza full of things done to us, and every stanza ending by pointing away from us.
"For it is by grace you have been saved, through faith — and this is not from yourselves, it is the gift of God — not by works, so that no one can boast.
For we are God's handiwork, created in Christ Jesus to do good works, which God prepared in advance for us to do."
"Car c'est par la grâce que vous êtes sauvés, par le moyen de la foi. Et cela ne vient pas de vous, c'est le don de Dieu. Ce n'est point par les œuvres, afin que personne ne se glorifie. Car nous sommes son ouvrage, ayant été créés en Jésus-Christ pour de bonnes œuvres, que Dieu a préparées d'avance, afin que nous les pratiquions."
Éphésiens 2:8–10 · Louis Segond 1910Verse 8 contains a question people have debated for centuries, and it is worth stating honestly rather than pretending it is settled.
And this is not from yourselves. What is this? Grace? Faith? The whole arrangement?
There is a grammatical clue. In Greek, this is neuter — while both grace and faith are feminine nouns. If Paul had meant faith specifically, the word would ordinarily have matched it.
So most readers take this to point at the whole transaction — saved, by grace, through faith, all of it. Not one component singled out as the gift, but the entire thing.
Which is the safer reading and also the larger one. It leaves nothing at all on our side of the ledger to be proud of — afin que personne ne se glorifie.
Le read verse 10 on the eleventh of August, and the note that morning was about poiēma — the word behind handiwork, used twice in the New Testament: once of the universe, once of us. Son ouvrage.
Today the second half of the verse is the one that matters, because of what she is doing this week.
Good works, which God prepared in advance for us to do. Que Dieu a préparées d'avance, afin que nous les pratiquions.
The works are not commissioned. They are prepared — and prepared before we arrive. The verb pictures something laid out and waiting, like a road already made.
And Le said this herself two days ago, in her own words and about her own situation. All we do is show up.
That is verse 10 exactly. Not passivity — the works must still be walked in, and walking is work. But nothing has to be invented, and nothing has to be forced into existence. The road was made first, and then the people were created to walk on it.
The feed places the Benimar at Beauvoir, on the road to Mont-Saint-Michel — within sight of an abbey built on a rock in a tidal bay, begun over a thousand years ago and added to for centuries.
Which makes an odd and useful backdrop for verse 9. Not by works, so that no one can boast.
Generations of people built that place stone by stone, and it is genuinely magnificent, and Paul's sentence still stands over it. The most impressive thing human beings can construct is not on the same page as what is being described here.
Verse 6 says the seating has already happened, and it is not on a rock in Normandy. Nous a fait asseoir ensemble dans les lieux célestes. Past tense, done, and nobody laid a stone for it.
"All of us also lived among them at one time... Like the rest, we were by nature deserving of wrath."
All of us — I'm part of his team.
Le has caught the hinge of the paragraph, and Paul built it so that nobody could stand outside it.
Verses 1 and 2 are you — the Gentile readers, the outsiders, the people a Pharisee would have expected to be describing. Then verse 3 turns: all of us also. Nous tous aussi.
And it is worth asking who the us is. A man circumcised the eighth day, of the tribe of Benjamin, a Pharisee — and by his own account blameless as to the righteousness of the law. If anyone in the New Testament had a case for an exemption clause, it was the writer of this sentence.
He writes himself into the indictment instead.
Which is exactly why but God works one verse later. The rescue has to cover the whole room, because the whole room was in the same condition. A remedy that only reached the obviously lost would have left the respectable exactly where they were.
And Le has said this from the beginning of these mornings, without needing Ephesians to tell her. Never a holy woman — only a forgiven one. Which is the only membership card the team issues, and it has the diagnosis printed on it rather than any merit.
"All of us — I'm part of his team."
Le's Heart · Beauvoir, Manche · Day one hundred and thirteen · Nous tous aussiIgnore the Chapter Break
The divisions were added a thousand years later. Chapter 1 says what God's power did to Christ; chapter 2 says the same three things happened to us. As two chapters, most readers miss it.
Ensemble, Ensemble
Three verbs all built on syn- — made alive with, raised with, seated with. The French keeps it: ressuscités ensemble, fait asseoir ensemble. Not power like His. The same act, extended.
But God
Three verses of diagnosis reversed by a conjunction and a noun. And the motive comes before the action — we are told why before we are told what.
All of Us Also
The pronouns move from "you" to "us" in one verse. The Pharisee who was blameless as to the law writes himself into the indictment — and that is why "But God" can cover the whole room.
Prepared in Advance
Not commissioned — prepared, and before we arrive. Le's own words two days ago: all we do is show up. The road was made first, then the people to walk on it.